data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bc3a4/bc3a4f620332fe3e7a4301401c25ed2d0be7eb77" alt="Download return to monkey island walkthrough for free"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6895f/6895f4e6da57c32dbb97acfc6f5df346560280ab" alt="download return to monkey island walkthrough for free download return to monkey island walkthrough for free"
After a quick reunion with the Cook, you can run through all of the dialogue options. Go to the right of the Scumm Bar again, past the three Pirate Leaders this time and into the kitchen. When you’ve examined it, you’ll be able to sneak it - though Wally is happy for them to be taken.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/45e5d/45e5d904ffd33aced5369161fc5446db639dabb4" alt="download return to monkey island walkthrough for free download return to monkey island walkthrough for free"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e582/4e5827f651e63d65826e61fde0c25ce9ac80dcae" alt="download return to monkey island walkthrough for free download return to monkey island walkthrough for free"
They’ll also suggest you just go along with LeChuck instead. This seems to get the pirate leaders a bit more interested in your venture but they won’t budge on helping. You can run through the dialogue options here, and it’ll end with “If you don’t take this opportunity, LeChuck will grab it.”
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63cac/63cac2d9e318fe6ce74ab49de3861123a3ed563f" alt="download return to monkey island walkthrough for free download return to monkey island walkthrough for free"
Here you can discuss funds, ship availability and putting together a crew. Whatever you choose, the Pirate Leaders will laugh. Respond with “I'm going to find the secret of Monkey Island.” Then answer however you like. Ask them “Is it you I should talk to about financing an expedition?” The next answer, whatever you choose, Lila will ask if she can kill Guybrush. Guybrush learns that these are, in fact, the new Pirate Leaders: Captain Madison, Lila and Trent, and they’re not interested in helping. Speak to the three people sitting where the Pirate Leaders should be. Head to the right and into the back of the Scumm Bar. When you start a new game, the trivia cards you previously collected will still be in the book when you pick it up again.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bc3a4/bc3a4f620332fe3e7a4301401c25ed2d0be7eb77" alt="Download return to monkey island walkthrough for free"